There I also want to answer with a ‘No’.
And I will explain why I think so.
Concised view of defined terms:
An ANP is a Host, an identifiable part of the personality, an act system, an Apparently Normal Personality
An EP is an Emotional Personality part of the main Personality. Each ANP can have stored all sorts of traumatized EP’s.
DID is a dissociative Identity Disorder with more than one identifiable Host act system (ANP’s)
DID is not a personality disorder
BPD is a Borderline Personality Disorder
An additional reaction from my therapist
after reading all my own writings on my Blogsite in order to explain a ‘structural dissociation of the personality’, the PTSD levels and the difference between DID and OSDD (complex PTSD level II and III). Probably a more compact clinical clarification and additional to the difference between ANP-EP and DID-OSDD by my therapist.
ANP’s don’t do to personification. They focus purely on tasks of everyday life and leave aside the EP’s of their consciousness mind. The influence of EP’s that they do experience, they experience not as a part of their own lives (they think it’s not a part of me)
EP’s don’t do to presentification (don’t live in the present time). They only think from out the past and don’t take notice of the fact that it’s already 2014.
In case of a OSDD there is one ANP and a lot more EP’s. Those EP’s don’t completely take over the consciousness mind of the ANP. So the ANP stays more a less in contact with the EP’s.
In case of a DID there are more than one ANP, and the EP’s can take over the consciousness mind of that or that particular ANP on that moment (that cause losing time in the daily functioning of the ANP’s). Amnesia is therefore also a typical symptom that goes with a tertiary dissociation of the personality.
So each person has only one personality !
Lets look closer to a personality that suffers a DID:
You can identify different DID-ANP’s of a personality that suffers a DID (stable act systems).
BPD is a personality disorder and not a partial identity disorder.
There you only could ask yourself the next question:
‘can a DID-ANP part suffer symptoms of a Borderline structure?’
Yes that is possible, but than a less that isn’t a BPD.
If the main host suffers a BPD, then the personality can’t handle or develop stable DID act systems (DID ANP’s EP’s). The total personality will always go under the influence of that personality disorder. One of the main symptoms of BPD is impulsive and acting out behavior, and they suffer also a very high influence of EP’s (emotional PERSONALITY parts). That isn’t a DID symptom, where one of the main symptoms is: More than one ANP and more than one EP = Together they form very stable act systems, identifiable DID-ANP’s, which don’t leave a lot of room to the EP’s to take control over the personality. The ANP’s are protecting each other, and the personality, against the influence of those painful EP’s (a survival system that didn’t learn how to synthesize)
A often heard explanation in answering the main question ‘can a part (ANP) of a DID personality suffer a Borderline personality disorder?’, is:
Most given answer: Yes, it is possible because there are people with both diagnosed disorders.
My first reaction there is: ‘Could it be that such a double diagnose is wrong?’
And ‘that’ is possible. Because diagnosing a trauma related dissociative disorder can only be done by experienced specialists which are trained to do so
Than de difference from a therapy need and point of view:
Identities of a personality which suffers a DID (ANP’s – apparently normal personality) protect each other against the influence of painful emotional personality parts. They don’t leave a lot of room to the EP’s to interfere (take control of the personality).
DID: In therapy and only within therapy, we learn the ANP’s to give room to the EP’s so they can make a start to integrate within the ANP (they need to give more room to the EP’s to work with)
OSDD: In therapy the Host (1 ANP) has to learn to take more control over the influence of EP’s, because there they have too much room to take over the behavior of the main APN (the EP’s have to much room and influence, in taking control of the personality).
Love to you all
A little language barrier
Sometimes a laugh is also very important to survive…
After 28 years no writing or speaking English, I have to learn English again to make myself understandable to you all.
But now I will learn you all a little bit Dutch.
So I’ll give you a Dutch sentence:
Mijn buurvrouw heeft koolmeesjes maar wat doet uw haan op mijn ezel.
My neighbor has great little birds, but what does your rooster on my donkey
And now go to google translator, see link: